Thanks for chiming in. You ask about my ideas by way of gender labeling… ugh. So many ideas.
I’ve at all times recognized actually strongly with the feminine gender, and haven’t recognized with the male gender. Nonetheless, I grew up in a binary society, and no different possibility was ever supplied.
My accomplice is non-binary. They scoff on the very concept of gender, seeing it totally as a societal assemble and discovering it with out a lot helpful worth.
I’ve spoken to scientists who’ve proven me variations in gender-variant elements of the brains women and men — and seen mind scans of trans ladies which emulate the ladies brains, not the boys brains.
I consider transgenderism could be greatest defined by neuroscience, not by biology.
Nonetheless, as I typically inform of us, having astigmatism doesn’t make you an optician, and having most cancers doesn’t make you an oncologist. I’ve the situation. I don’t have the scientific acumen to debate the situation at a tutorial stage.
However I can let you know about people. And I can let you know about ideologies. I can let you know how Darwin’s legitimate principle of evolution was appropriated to develop into Social Darwinism — resulting in a lot injustice, a lot struggling.
We’ve tried “separate however equal,” and it didn’t work. (learn in regards to the integration efforts of Pauli Murray — one in every of my private heroes).
When you make trans ladies “separate however equal” from ladies, inevitably we’ll find yourself in a ghetto.
An important answer is to only care much less about gender. I used to be simply on the LinkedIn headquarters in San Francisco — they’ve gender-agnostic loos. As I walked in to the restroom, a person held the door for me. I walked previous three urinals to my proper to seek out a number of ladies making use of make-up by the sinks and mirrors. The stalls had been reverse the mirrors, and ladies, queer people and males got here out and in. Everybody was well mannered and courteous, and there was no downside. It allowed me to check a distinct model of the world.
One other problem together with your 5 genders is that when once more we’d be creating constructs for individuals to evolve to. I depend amongst my pals people who find themselves cisgender and hetero, femme lesbians, butch lesbians, post-op trans ladies, pre-op and non-op trans people, a transfeminine (figuring out feminine however with no hormonal or surgical interventions), a number of non-binaries, a genderfluid, and many others. and many others.
So my ideas are nonetheless… considering. What I do know is:
a) Inflexible gender roles and their enforcement haven’t led to fully-realized people
b) Permitting freedom of self-identification and self-expression yields extra happiness and doesn’t result in hurt;
c) Creating mounted brackets can result in apartheids and exclusion, particularly when you will have huge unbalances of quantity, company, wealth, and many others.
I hope that is, a minimum of, meals for thought. 🙂
PS: As a part of my Empowered Trans Lady Summit, I interviewed Prof. Robert Sapolsky, of the Dept. of Neurobiology at Stanford. You would possibly take pleasure in his insights.